Ironically, the profiling measures Malkin advocates today, such as selective monitoring of aliens and visitors from countries with terrorist links, are moderate and fairly sensible. She is right that it's ludicrous to invoke Japanese internment as a parallel. But surely, defending something as extreme as mass internment can only undermine her case. The people Malkin dubs "profiling alarmists" argue that if you accept any ethnic profiling, you're on a slippery slope to defending internment camps. And Malkin does her best to prove it for them. But this doesn't mean that Malkin's book -- the new featured selection of the Conservative Book Club -- is harmless.
Among the conservative faithful, it is likely to promote anti-immigrant bias, contempt for civil liberties, and the attitude that acknowledging the racism of our past is for namby-pamby liberals or America-hating lefties. And that's a shame. It was President Reagan, a great conservative, who first authorized reparations for Japanese-American internees and issued an apology for the injustice done to them.
For conservatives to embrace Malkin's extremism is a betrayal of his legacy. Cathy Young is a co-editor at Reason magazine. No less a figure than James McNaughton, a senior U. Lowman fervently believes that the raw [MAGIC] intercepts speak for themselves and trump other sources of intelligence on the Japanese American community.
However, the messages speak more of intentions than results.
The hints contained in MAGIC, if decision-makers paid them any heed at all, were not by themselves sufficient to justify the mass evacuation and incarceration of over , civilians. He errs in giving absolute primacy to communications intelligence, no matter how ambiguous.
His polemics should be viewed as symptomatic of the lingering bitterness stemming from Pearl Harbor and the emotions raised by apologies and compensation. So why does Malkin base her book on the work of a discredited U. Your guess is as good as mine. But recycling discredited historical ideas seems to be a Fox, and Malkin, stock in trade. In my opinion, Malkin finally shows a few moral compunctions; or perhaps she made a shrewd judgment that she could say many patently outrageous things here, but calling for Arab internment would be one step too far.
But as a result, she betrays a failure of nerve in refusing to follow her thesis through to its logical conclusion. Let me finally add one highly personal element to this debate. Not only am I a grandchild of immigrants, I am Jewish and a number of my great aunts and uncles died in the Holocaust.tropdismovsnated.tk
Europeans Were Sent to U.S. Internment Camps During WW II, too | History News Network
Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.
- The Quality of Mercy: Reflections on Shakespeare;
- In Defense of Internment: The Case for 'Racial Profiling' in World War II and the War on Terror?
- Defending Repression?
- The Crimson Fairy: Lucky Luck and Other Stories.
- Econometrics: Alchemy or Science?: Essays in Econometric Methodology.
- Your audiobook is waiting….
- Account Options.
If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again. Go to Mobile Site.
Atkins Dec 8, reply to c. Nov 7, 2 In Response to Olsen Thiery Oct 7, Japanese Internment [92 words] K. Jarvis Sep 2, 3 against internment [ words] Anthony Aug 24, 1 Response to Barbara Hoshiko [ words] Farida Faizi Jun 6, 1 Need more specificity [ words] Konrad Mar 30, 2 This is how hate starts: response to "Andrew" [ words] Jackie Mar 11, According to the Islamists, Islam is not a peaceful religion. Donne Feb 8, D. Holland Jan 5, Profiling [23 words] Richard Baldwin Jan 5, 1 Supporting racial profiling but opposing internment [ words] Jonathan Rick Jan 5, 1 Principles [49 words] Tom Jan 5, Why repeat a mistake [ words] Craig Jan 5, 1 Saudi Arabia's misplaced priorities [67 words] Hari Iyer Jan 5, This article should be required reading!
In Defense of Internment: The Case for Racial Profiling in World War II and the War on Terror
Pipes is right [ words] W. Hopwood Jan 2, Pipes and Malkin are correct. Pipes [ words] B.
Alotaibi Dec 31, How about the White Guys? Dec 29, Malkin [22 words] S. Panda Dec 29, As usual, your brilliant remarks Phil Corson Dec 28, History can teach so let it [ words] Kathryn Mcguire Apr 25, But was it truly necessary? Moore Dec 28, Start with potential immigrants [ words] Pat Dec 28, Thank You, Voices of Reason [ words] Tim Dec 28, Selecting the bad guys [70 words] Jim Dec 28, Irrefutable logic once again!
Again you've hit just the right note. Fox Dec 28, Racial issue? Email Address: optional.
Title of Comments:. Email me if someone replies to my comment. China Disrupts the Middle East. Follow Daniel Pipes. Fifty Years of Fascination. Other Languages. Mailing List. German Hindi Italian Japanese Polish. Russian Spanish Swedish. Israel recently stripped Israeli citizens who have joined Isis of their citizenship [23 words]. All attempts to justify it run into a simple fact Martial Law in Hawaii and the Niihau incident [ words].
Thank you Henry for strengthening my Argument [ words]. Once again, the Right is wrong. Once again the politically correct are wrong [ words]. Atkins [66 words]. The others According to the Islamists, Islam is not a peaceful religion. Oh please This is a response to a question from "ploome" on the source of my information on Thomas Jefferson and "Adja" [ words].
Interpreting the Koran [ words].